Get Inspiration and
100 Simple Healthy Recipes

Buy the book
HARMONY
BOOKS

Worst Snack of 2012

29   December 19, 2012   ‹ Older     Newer ›

Worst Snack 2012

My picture here is supposed to resemble a mug shot. Yes, Hershey’s Milk Shake you are in big trouble.

Before I continue, if you don’t think I feel a bit ridiculous complaining about snacks after our nation’s latest tragedy - I do. I don’t want you, dear reader, to think that I hadn’t noticed what happened in Newtown, CT. But, my job is to talk about food and I am sticking to it to calm myself down.

Every year, I elect myself to choose the "Worst Snack of the Year". One of my early choices, the Hostess Fruit Pie, no longer exists. Maybe I had something to do with that?

Now, I will vent some of my anger on this flavored milk that I unwittingly purchased for my children, ages six and eight. They saw this in a deli where we were buying a sandwich and I thought it was flavored milk.

Flavored milk is a treat for my kids, though they purchase it at school. The school has a lower added sugar variety called “TruMoo” that has about 15 grams added sugar per 12 ounces. They only buy 8 ounces so they get 10 grams of added sugar (or 2 teaspoons).

Check this out:

50 grams of sugar!! For 12 ounces of milk, you would expect about 16 grams of sugar from lactose and then Hershey’s decided to add 34 grams of sugar - just under 7 teaspoons of sugar. In one serving there are 10 teaspoons of sugar.

Another problem is the packaging. See those lovely strawberries? There are three of them on the outside and the whole container is strawberry red.

Take a gander at the ingredient list:

Ummm, strawberries??? Nope. I do see “natural and artificial flavors” and to Hershey’s credit it does say “strawberry flavored” and not “real strawberries”. I guess since you didn’t use strawberries now we need RED #40 and BLUE #1 to make it pink.

To summarize:

I find this product misleading and I think it is just plain unnecessary to add so much sugar. While there is the added benefit of milk (versus soda) of protein and calcium, the rest of the product is terrible.

My advice is to be sure that you buy "Strawberry Flavored Milk" and not a "Milkshake" if you can remember that. Argh.


Other posts you might like:

Worst Snack of 2011Worst and Best Snack of 2011

Am I qualified to give out awards for the BEST and WORST snack of 2011? Probably not, but I'm going to do it anyway..... read more

The Worst Snack of 2010The Worst Snack of 2010

It was a difficult decision. Snack Girl has made her choice. read more




29 Comments:

Not to mention the 360 mg of sodium!!!!!

Marcia on December 19, 2012

Ewwww!! I can see why it is the worse snack! It sounds gross!! I can't believe Hershey's would make something so bad, well I guess I can. I heard there chocolate is made with lard! Gross!!

Jennifer @ Peanut Butter and Peppers on December 19, 2012

Well I will add that the milk is no good either. Milk makes your body acidic...and your body naturally strips calcium from bones to balance the acid level. To think you are gaining calcium from milk is a joke. We consume more milk and dairy than any other country and have the worst osteoporosis rates.

Annette on December 19, 2012

Thank you Snack Girl for making people think twice before they buy something. I wish I didn't have to read the ingredients in every single thing I buy, but that is the case if you don't want all the additives, not to mention all the sugar and salt that companies feel they have to add for the public to buy. I try to do the 5 ingredient rule, but it's not always an option.

Sue on December 19, 2012

Annette- I've heard that before and I'm not sure I believe it. Do you have a link to a study?

Andrea on December 19, 2012

I think alot of these bottled milks are bad for you. My sister buys my nephew the extreme choc milk variety (I think that's the name). I read her the label one time 210 cal. And mind you the bottle contains 2 servings. For a 4 yr. old! Unfortunately it fell on deaf ears. As for the osteoporosis, not sure if it's true or not, but my mother has it and she hates dairy! No milk cheese or eggs and she's been that way since childhood, still got the disease

Erin on December 19, 2012

Oh god, that's just gross. Even as a kid, I didn't want to eat that!

Stephanie Goldman on December 19, 2012

Hi Andrea. Yes, the China Study is the biggest...but there are many. That's the biggest, lengthiest study (over years) in history on a plant-based diet and there is plenty of research there. Amazon has the book. Erin...makes sense...dairy is certainly not the only cause; many things cause an acid level in the body...meat, soda pop, etc. which leads to leaching calcium from the body. Overall, the American diet is acidic...which creates a breading ground for disease of all kinds.

Annette on December 19, 2012

@Andrea (I hope Annette doesn't mind my stepping in here)- I think this http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/24/health/24brod.html may help with some cited studies.

Big takeaways from that article for me:

"Bones are the storage tank for calcium compounds that regulate the acid-base balance of the blood, which must be maintained within a very narrow range. When the blood becomes even slightly too acid, alkaline calcium compounds — like calcium carbonate, the acid-neutralizer in Tums — are leached from bones to reduce the acidity.

...

"The researchers note that fruits and vegetables are predominantly metabolized to alkaline bicarbonate, whereas proteins and cereal grains are metabolized to acids. The more protein people consume beyond the body’s true needs, the more acidic their blood can become and the more alkaline compounds are needed to neutralize the acid.

...

"The Dawson-Hughes team concluded that increasing the alkaline content of the diet by eating more fruits and vegetables should be studied as a safe and low-cost approach to preventing osteoporosis and improving bone health in older Americans.

...

"In their exhaustive review of the scientific literature, Dr. Lanou and Mr. Castleman found that “two-thirds of clinical trials show that milk, dairy foods and calcium supplements do not prevent fractures.” They conclude that the high fracture rate in countries that consume the most milk and dairy products results from the fact that “these affluent Western countries also consume the most meat, poultry and fish.”

Hope that helps.

Andy D on December 19, 2012

Not to mention all the other additives. Carrageenan is a carcinogen.

Cristina @ An Organic Wife on December 19, 2012

Don't mind at all Andy! Thank you for contributing. The more awareness there is, the more things can change. There is a lot of money behind the dairy industry and we have been so trained to think "milk, it does a body good" that it's hard to think otherwise. Truth is, we have to educate ourselves about our health.

Annette on December 19, 2012

@Annette- I realize that it's not everyone's cup of tea when I paraphrase Melanie Joy (www.carnism.com), but I think that if people are making choices, they need to be *informed* choices. (Her actual line is "Without awareness, there is no free choice.")

If someone wants to eat animal products of any kind, that's clearly their choice, but I contend that we should all get the facts and not follow (biased) industry guidance to do so.

But I feel that I'm coming dangerously close to hijacking this "worst-snack" thread and I don't want Lisa to put a "strawberry" milkshake in my stocking... :)

Andy D on December 19, 2012

Nobody is getting a Strawberry Milkshake. Hijack away.

Snack Girl on December 19, 2012

I literally gasped when I saw the sugar content! A treat once in a great while is okay, this is exorbitant, but it is not marketed as nutritious, like some yogurts that have just as much sugar per ounce. I hope people are learning to read their labels!

Valerie on December 19, 2012

Great post!

Trevor LaRene on December 19, 2012

Thank you. I'm a grandmother and may not have double checked "milk" if the girls asked for it.

Marie on December 19, 2012

I think you're very wise not to comment on the news. As tragic as it is, your site is not a news site, it's a reference site where people come to look for food info, recipes, etc. - and that's excellent! Good for you for keeping yourself focused!

Christine L. on December 19, 2012

And the carbs at 56g, that is equal to 56 spoons of extra sugar added to the 50g of sugar already in it. Yipes 106g total of sugar in one serving. Hopefully this will disappear too.

Maria on December 19, 2012

@Christine L. - Thank you for the positive feedback. I have been struggling with what to do because I am a writer with an audience. I am glad you liked my solution which was to acknowledge - and not comment - on the news.

Snack Girl on December 19, 2012

SMH

fitfoodiele on December 19, 2012

Maria, the total carbohydrates on the label includes sugars. (This indicates there are 6g carbs that are not sugar but majority is sugar) Harvard Healthy Plate does not put as much emphasis on milk/dairy intake and suggest alternate sources for calcium
http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/calcium-and-milk/index.html

Sally on December 19, 2012

I looked at the ingredients and said - ugh.

I'd rather make my own flavored milk :-)

Monica.

MonicaP on December 19, 2012

Hershey's... this is just gross! But it does follow their philosophy of low quality with too much sugar, which pretty much defines their chocolate as well. I have never understood why anyone buys it after trying a good chocolate. Truly I should blame the consumers though, I guess.

Brian Harward on December 19, 2012

good heavens!!! 50 grams of sugar!!!!!! gross!

Gail on December 19, 2012

I just vomited! THAT IS REPULSIVE!!! The worst part is that the bottle says A+ right on the front, so people who don't really READ labels, just see the A+ and assume it's healthy! OMG this kills me just looking at it!! Imagine if I ingested it! :(

GiGi Eats Celebrities on December 20, 2012

I don't normally comment but I love to read the blog. Even the bottle looks gross to me. I am not good at being healthy all the time and I believe treats are good occasionally but it always surprises me what my friends and family allow their kids to have all the time. I have one cousin who has taught her children that Gatorade is a juice.

Jodi on December 24, 2012

I'm late to this party, but all I can think is how EASY it would be to make a delicious strawberry shake with REAL strawberries! ( I know...convienence food, etc., but sheesh!)
I agree with Christine too. Thank you. ;)

Jessica on January 7, 2013

The Hostess fruit pies were available in outlet stores and were alive and well in parts of the East coast , of course Hostess has fallen now - but for how long?

H on April 1, 2013

I HATE trumoo though. It taste HORRIBLE! But that is just my opinion

Hailey on May 5, 2013


Add a comment:

(required)

(required, never published)

(optional)


Welcome! I’m Lisa. I write about simple snacks, healthy recipes, and products that help me WIN my battle with donuts!

100+ Healthy Snack Ideas

Get new posts by email
 

SNACK GIRL TO THE RESCUE!

A Real-Life Guide to Losing Weight and Getting Healthy with 100 Recipes Under 400 Calories

Read the First Chapter

Inspirational Advice

100 Recipes Under 400 Calories

I will show you how small, easy tweaks can change your lifestyle to be healthier and happier.

  • Want to avoid the office donuts? Chapter 3: Everyday Temptations
  • Need to unstick your butt from the couch? Chapter 5: Exercise
  • After a stressful day are your best friends Ben & Jerry? Chapter 4: Emotional Eating
  • Know you need to eat more vegetables? Chapter 2: Healthy Cooking

With 100 recipes for fun, quick, and affordable meals and snacks—all under 400 calories and Weight Watchers friendly. The recipes have been tested by home chefs and are delicious, easy, and simple, most have never been published on Snack-Girl.com.

Find out more...